|
One
of the major deficits that characterize Autism
Spectrum Disorders (ASD) is impaired speech and
language. The development of speech and language may
be deviant, delayed or absent. These deficits vary
and can range from no speech at all, to complex
speech with errors. Common errors may include
staying on a topic of interest for too long,
repeating parts of other conversations, difficulty
with eye contact while speaking, changing topics
rapidly, speaking in a monotonic voice and not
knowing when to use particular Language (for
example, a greeting, or slang).
-
Psychologist Okey Martins Nwokolo (PhD) in a
therapaeutic session with an autistic child -
One of the major deficits that characterize Autism
Spectrum Disorders (ASD) is impaired speech and
language. The development of speech and language may
be deviant, delayed or absent. These deficits vary
and can range from no speech at all, to complex
speech with errors. Common errors may include
staying on a topic of interest for too long,
repeating parts of other conversations, difficulty
with eye contact while speaking, changing topics
rapidly, speaking in a monotonic voice and not
knowing when to use particular Language (for
example, a greeting, or slang).
COMMON SPEECH AND LANGUAGE PROBLEMS IN AUTISM
v Some children with autism start to develop speech
and at about age 2 begin to lose words previously
acquired.
v Others may develop expressive language far in
advance of their expected age. In many such cases,
the children use terms that are advanced for their
age, and the words are used incorrectly or out of
context.
v Verbal skills are often devoid of descriptive and
pragramatic language. Pragmatics is the language we
use in everyday social contexts and to make our
needs known. Children with autism often have
difficulties with describing how or what they feel,
make requests, ask questions to clarify a topic; or
even realize that they have a question or reaction
due to a lack of pragmatics.
v Another speech and language problems often seen in
individuals with autism is pronoun reversal. Their
language is often lacking in the use of personal
pronouns, which are abstract forms of reference
(Murray-Slutsky & Paris, 2000.)
v These children may laugh when you reprimand them,
or smile when they say they are angry. Their facial
expressions may not correlate with their verbal
messages. Children who do not have autism but who
have speech delays, actually compensate for their
lack of language through gesture, body language, and
facial expression. Autism, however, affect the
child’s sense of how to communicate.
SOME SENSORY PROCESSING ISSUES IN AUTISM
According to Murray-Slutsky & Paris (2000),
individuals with autism spectrum disorders have
impaired sensory systems. They may fail to react or
to register changes and things in their environment.
Sensory registration is a process that occurs on a
sub-conscious level within the brain and enables us
to recognize changes within our environment and turn
to the stimulus. Turning to stimulus or making some
other type of reaction to it is known as the
orienting response. A child with autism may not turn
or respond when called. Some may fail to register a
toy in their environment and to them such a toy is
non-existent. Some others may fail to register that
they are drooling and make no attempt to wipe face
or react when bitten by an insect. In her view,
Ayres (1979), reported that children with autism
lack or at least have an inconsistent orienting
response. She referred such a children’s
“registration” function as capricious, citing that
the brain may decide to register a sensory input one
day, but not register something similar another day.
If the child does not register something, how can he
orient to it? (Murray - Slutsky & Paris, 2000).
Ayres (1979) described two response patterns to
sensory stimuli namely:
Hyporesponsive system
Hyperresponsive system
Hyporesponsive systems:- In children with
hyporesponsive systems, sensory stimuli such as
tactile, auditory, proprioceptive, and vestibular
input may not register unless they are magnified in
intensity. For example, children who can’t feel
their touch on certain object may press too hard or
break those objects. They may appear not to hear or
tune out if they cannot perceive auditory input. If
a child cannot register the information that his
muscles and joints are sending to his brain, he may
not know where his arms or legs are in space or how
to use them in a coordinated fashion. His arm or leg
placement may be awkward, his ability to sit in a
chair impaired and he will appear uncoordinated or
clumsy.
Hyporesponsive children are often over-active
children. They remain in constant motion because
they lack the balance to stay in one place; they
charge ahead crashing into objects.
Hyperresponsive system: Ayres, (1973) described the
hyperresponsive systems as one in which the system
may overreact to stimuli. These may include
intolerance of movement (a result of hyperactive
response to vestibular input), tactile defensiveness
(the result of overreaction to tactile stimuli, and
auditory hyper sensitively as examples of hyper
responsive systems.
It is evident from the above theory that children
with hyporesponsive and or hyper responsive systems
have inconsistent responses to sensory input and
therefore have a modulation disorder (Ayres and
Tickle, 1980). Similarly, knickerbockers, (1980)
proposed that the oral defensiveness often seen in
these children may be another example of a sensory
system that is not only hyporesponsive to oral
input, but lacking in the ability to process the
sensory input bombarding it. Lovaas and Colleagues
(1971) observed that when presented with multiple
stimuli, children with autism tend to overfocus on
one mode of sensory input rather than integrate all
of the presenting stimuli. He proposed that these
children may fail to manage multiple stimuli in
their environment.
Murray-slutsky and Paris (2000) therefore suggested
that for a child to benefit from any teaching or
learning effort, such a child should be helped to
function within a window called calm-alert state.
They defined the calm-alert as a window in which a
person’s ability to function is maximized. In this
state, the child has a balance between the ability
to attend to a stimulus or task, and the level of
arousal within his brains and bodies to prepare him
to respond.
A child with a problem in registering and modulating
sensory input will exhibit problems in learning,
language, and purposeful interaction; and also will
have difficulty with ideation or concept formation,
initiation, motor planning, and organization of
behaviours (Ayres and Tickle, 1980). Hence learning,
language and purposeful interactions depend upon
registering information, filtering extraneous input,
and having an optimal state of arousal to attend to
a task, a child with a sensory modulation disorder
will be hampered in all of these areas.
Many children with autism are in a state of either
underarousal or overarousal. The underarousal child
will miss much input and therefore, fail to register
and respond to it. The overaroused child is
bombarded by a constant stream of unfiltered input
and the intense stress posed by changing and
unpredictable situations. The stress from this
overwhelming stimulation may easily lead to sensory
over load, shutdown, over focusing, disorganized and
disruptive behavior.
THE CASE OF MAJE
At 2 years of age Maje had started to vocalize and
develop speech. Suddenly, at about his 29th month,
parents observed that Maje began to lose the words
he had previously acquired. Though his vocabulary
bank at the time contained only 5 words (bye “bei”,
Mama “maama”, Dad “Da-da-daaa”, Me “Mii” and Oh-oh
“Oh-o”), 2 of which are only sounds that sounded
like real words, they were often non-spontaneous. He
would drag parents or siblings hands toward a
desired object; or throw tantrums when he wants
something. Parents were quite displeased about
Maje’s regression. Maje babbled with a variety of
sounds, but he had none of the words expected of a
2-year old. His disruptive behaviours increased,
with lots of fleeting eye contact, inattention and
hyperactivivity. Communication was extremely
difficult with siblings; parents and other adults.
He had very poor receptive language and did not
follow simple instructions such as sit, go, come,
give, take, wave and so on). In addition to his
language and communication problems, Maje also has
low muscle tone and several sensory issues
VERBAL IMITATION TRANINING TECHNIQUE
Verbal imitation is an effort directed at teaching a
child how to talk by teaching him how to imitate
speech, beginning with sounds and words. Most
children with ASD who are either mute or non-verbal
find it extremely difficult to imitate speech.
Majority of them find it easier to imitate gestures
and actions (for example clapping, waving)
This technique was popularized by Lovaas, (1981) and
uses behaviour modification principles to train
children to develop speech. The greater the amount
of time spent on this exercise the better the
outcome. According to Lovaas (1981), the amount of
time you put into verbal imitation training depends
on how important you feel it is for the child to
talk, relative to other skills he needs to acquire.
In Lovaas’s technique, half of the teaching time is
spent on language programmes, which in the beginning
means an upward of 4 hours a day spent teaching the
non-verbal child to imitate speech. To avoid
monotony, therapists intersperse verbal imitation
training with non-verbal imitation and other drills.
Some children will learn to talk using the Lovaas
method of verbal imitation while some may not.
Lovaas (1981) warns therapists to note that not all
children will learn to talk using this technique.
Unfortunately, it is difficult to say beforehand
which child will benefit from this technique and
which will not. Nevertheless, Lovaas suggested the
following:
v If the child is over 6 years old, and if he is not
making some sounds or words involving “difficult”
consonants (such as k, g, p), but merely gives an
occasional (“ooh,” “ah”), then he is likely to
progress very slowly. He will progress quickly if he
is less than 6 years and already using complicated
vowel – consonants corroborations.
v Consider dropping the programme if after 2 or 3
months on verbal imitation training and your child
cannot imitate 5 or more succinct sounds. You may
want to come back to it later.
PROCEDURE USED TO TEACH MAJE TO VOCALISE AND
IMITATE SOUNDS
v We scheduled Maje for an 8 hour per day
one-one-one therapy in his natural environment (
home).
v We worked on his attending behaviours (such as
learning correct responses to simple instructions
like, sit, give, take, come, go and look). Other
pre-requisite skills developed include focusing/eye
contact, motor imitation (he progressed from one
step to 2 step instructions) and gesture imitation.
v We assessed and identified effective reinforcers
to be used to reward Maje
v We designed a clutter and noise free work area
where distraction is highly minimal. Extraneous
stimuli were kept under maximum control.
v Because of his sensory issues which included
overarousal and hyperresponsivity, we applied
sensory integration exercises to get Maje to a calm
alert state.
The integration exercises included –
>- Brushing (Wilbarger protocol)
> Joint compression
> Deep pressure
> Brain Buttons
> Cross crawl
> Brain Gym
> Drink water
> Hook ups
> Handle exercise
These exercises were done routinely and consistently
with songs which are repeatedly sung every session.
Once this procedure is completed, Maje is certainly
in relaxed, calm-alert and ready to work.
HOW MAJE WAS TAUGHT TO VOCALISE
AIM: The goal of the vocalization training is to
increase the frequency of his vocalizations. A
vocalization is any sound made with the vocal cords,
including grunts, laughter, babbling, “ahs “and
“ee’s (Lovaas, 1981).
We wanted Maje to learn that verbalizing will be
rewarded with food (banana, pineapple), and praise,
and that he can control the supply of these rewards
by making sounds.
PHASE 1: INCREASING VOCALISATIONS
STEP 1a: Get child to feel calm, released and
motivated to work. Create a friendly atmosphere.
STEP 1b: Seat with child face to face
STEP 2: Say, “Talk” and immediately reward each
vocal response with food and praise. If you are
doing it right, your pleasant, happy manner, your
timing of “Talk”, and the nature of your rewards
should help prompt vocalizations which you can
reward.
STEP 3: If child does not make any sounds, wet get
creative. Prompt him physically by finger prompts,
mouth prompt. Tickle, caress the child or sing a
song as you make him to jump or swing.
Immediately reinforce any sound that your child
makes. When that didn’t work, we step down and teach
imitation of facial expressions.
PHASE 11: CONTROLLING VOCALISATIONS
Our aim in phase one was to teach Maje that he could
control the supply of banana/pineapple. In phase 11,
we aim to get him to respond upon command; when
asked to “Talk”. The goal is to teach him to make
vocalization within 3 seconds after the therapist
says ‘TALK”. He will only be rewarded if he first
listens to the therapist vocalize. There are four
steps:
STEP 1: Sit face to face with child, and about 1 – 2
feet apart.
STEP 2: Say “Talk”, and reinforce each vocal
response that occurs within about 3 seconds after
your demand with praise and food. Continue trials
until the child makes a vocal response to your
instruction within about 3 seconds for 10
consecutive trials.
STEP 3: Reduce the interval between your instruction
and his response to about 2 seconds.
STEP 4: When the child has successded at a 2 second
interval for about 10 consecutive trials, the
interval is further reduced to 1 second. When the
child has made vocal responses within 1 second after
you say “Talk” for 10 consecutive trials, go on to
phase 3. Be consistent in data collection.
PHASE 111: IMITATION OF SOUNDS
Here we are ready to teach the child to imitate
specific sounds which he will later use in saying
words. The child should initially learn to imitate
about 10 sounds, including at least 3 consonants.
The first sounds to train were sounds that the child
frequently emitted while we tried to increase
vocalization or just some easy sounds.
a (“ah”)
o (“oh”)
d (“duh”)
m (“mm”)
f (“ef”)
e (“ee”)
k (“kuh”)
t (“tuh”)
Teaching the first sounds
STEP 1: You and your child should not face to face 1
-2 face apart
STEP 2: On each trial, say one sound, such as “ah”
using an echo mic
STEP 3: On the first five trials, any sound that the
child makes within 3 seconds of your sound is to be
reinforced even if it is just a rough approximation
of the sound you made. For example, “eh” would be
acceptable for “ah” at the early stage.
STEP 4: If the child fails to match the sounds
roughly or correctly, use visual /physical
prompting. Use mouth prompt – e.g. when saying “ah”
open your mouth very wide. Re ward the child for
imitating the shape of your mouth, whether or not he
vocalizes. You may even finger prompt by opening his
mouth for him. Continue visual prompting procedure
until the child has roughly approximated the sound
you made for 5 consecutive trials.
In the manual prompting procedure, you hold the
child’s mouth in the appropriate shape where the
child vocalizes. For example, you can manually
prompt the labial sounds (p, b, m) by holding the
child’s lips together when he vocalizes. Gradually
fade the prompt until the child has roughly
approximated your vocalization without any prompting
for 5 consecutive trials.
STEP 5: Shape the child’s response to more closely
match your vocalization. On successive trials
reinforce responses that closely match yours.
Continue to shape this until the child can correctly
imitate the sound that you make. When the child has
correctly imitated the first sound for 10
consecutive trials, imitation of the second sound
can begin.
TEACHING MAJE THE SECOND SOUND
The second sound “oh” that Maje learnt is quite
different from the first sound. We repeated steps1
through 6, used in teaching the first sound.
In addition, we did random rotation with the two
sounds “mm”, “oh”, “mm”, “oh” “oh” “mm”. We
continued to present trials in random rotation until
the child imitated correctly to criterion. In this
fashion, we continued up to the tenth sound.
After he acquired each new sound, presentation of
the new sounds were mixed with presentations of the
sounds learned earlier.
When he learnt to imitate 6 – 10 sounds, we began a
next phase of building syllabus and words. For
example we worked on consonant – vowel combinations
such as CV and CVCV forms.
C V
A E I O U
B Ba Be bi bo bu
C ka ke ki ko ku
D da de di do du
…..up to letter Z
CV CV
Baba bebe bi,bi bobo bubu
etc
PHASE IV: TEACHING IMITATION OF WORDS
We made a word list chosen from sounds that Maje
could readily imitate. The words include:
Papa banana down wee wee
Mummy apple we toilet
Bye bye water go me
TEACHING THE FIRST WORD
STEP 1: For the first 20 – 50 trials the therapists
says a word, such as “bye bye” and reinforce any
approximations that include the main sounds in the
word.
STEP 2: Reward approximations and shape the words
until they sound closely with yours and consistently
so.
Therapist: “Bai bai”
Child: Ba
Therapist: Good...bai bai
Child: “ba” ba”
Therapist: Well done
Continue shaping and adding new words from the word
list. As the child learns to imitate his first
words, he may show problems in the areas of pitch,
volume, and overall speed with which he says his
first words. These problems can be remedied using
shaping and imitation.
When Maje learnt to articulate sounds, a new
challenge set in – the challenge of meaning and
programtics. So we used similar reinforcement
procedures to teach him how to mand (request) e.g.
Maje says “water” and gets water; Tact (label) e.g.
show him a glass of water and ask “Maje what is
this?”.
Today Maje is mainstreamed and attends a regular
school. Because of his behaviour and attention
issues a facilitator shadows him at school. |